HOME
REGISTER/LOGIN
FREE NEWSLETTER
XML|RSS
Advanced Search
PODCAST
VIDEO
AVWEB INSIDER
AVweb Insider

April 5, 2010

Better To Treat Depressed Pilots

By Brent Blue, M.D.

As one AME put it, maybe the guy who flew into the building in Austin would not have if he had been treated with antidepressants.

In a long overdue decision, the FAA has approved the use of four anti-depressant medications (Prozac, Zoloft, Celexa, and Lexapro) for use by pilots with 1st, 2nd, and 3rd class medical certificates. This decision has been based on recommendations from various organizations from the Aerospace Medical Association to the AOPA to the U.S. Army as well as a progressive Federal Air Surgeon and his staff.

There are caveats. The pilot must be stable on the medication for 12 months and must have a letter from the treating psychiatrist attesting to the stability of the condition. Since most people on antidepressants are treated by primary care physicians (PCP), I am not sure whether the FAA will require pilots to see a psychiatrist as a consultant to affirm what the PCP has already stated.

In an interesting twist, the FAA is also offering amnesty to any pilot who is on antidepressants who reports the use within the next six months. However, those pilots will be grounded until they meet the requirements of the new order which I would estimate at four to 12 weeks. The pilots must have been stable on one of the approved medications for 12 months so I am not sure how many pilots will be forthcoming if they are on one of the nonapproved medications and face grounding for a year.

I think this is a good decision. Mild to moderate depression is basically a medical illness with psychological symptoms. Since the advent of selective seratonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs), many with this problem have been treated so successfully that literally their lives were changed.

Pilots are no different. Of all the reasons I have had to deny a pilot medical over 25 plus years, the use of antidepressants has been the number one reason. The depression was well controlled and there were no side effects of the medications.

The use of antidepressants was not going to happen under the previous Federal Air Surgeon whose main psychiatric advisor was dead set against the use of the medications. mostly based on older medications which had lots of side effects and did not work very well. Fortunately, under FAS Dr. Fred Tilton, a much more enlightened approach to medical problems has emerged out of Washington with the support of Dr. Warren Silberman, Chief of Airmen Certification for the FAA's Aerospace Medical Certification Institute. I applaud the Dr. Tilton for his approval of this new policy. In the world of "take no risk" bureaucrats, Dr. Tilton is a star in the FAA.


Comments

While the FAA can be applauded for this long, long overdue action, it remains a bureaucratically-ossified agency that can't seem to comprehend that there's a difference between medicines that "are" mind-altering and those that prevent the mind from becoming altered.

posted by Richard Carden on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

It's about time! Now I'm hoping to see the FAA do away with the third class medical - I understand the exam for commercial operations, but for private pilots I think it's a little ridiculous.

posted by Josh Johnson on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

I also applaud this move. I recall reading that Australia has allowed pilots on antidepressants to fly for some years, reasoning that un-depressed pilots are safer than depressed pilots. I would have liked the FAA to address SSRIs as a class, however: We use SSRIs for more than depression. They can be used as adjuncts in treating neuritic pain, and in migraine prophylaxis, in patients who do not have a concurrent psychiatric diagnosis. If taking an SSRI for an off-label, i.e., non-psychiatric purpose, I can't see grounding someone...just requiring appropriate medical documentation.

posted by Stan Hall on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

I have suffered from mild depression for many years and stopped taking Zoloft in order to get a pilot medical. I am pleased at this new enlightenment but struggling with the thought that to go back on them would require a twelve month grounding. I'd rather stay off them. That seems a bit of a negative consequence under the circumstances.

posted by Randy Walton on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

The FAA being progressive? Finally. But there is much more to this story especially known by those of us medications have affected. And the strict proceedures these pilots need to follow? Until you are one of these affected types, you have no idea. An example. Me. Many years ago after some rather tramatic experiences, I sought out a psychologist for support. He gave me a antidepressants for a possible means of support. After a number of years and a number of different anitdeppresants, I with approval of my doctor quit them all! Worked on other issues. Now in retrospect over two years later, I can say that antideppresants didn"t work for me and the diagnosis was just a shot in the dark. But I have paid the price as far as flying goes. As I mentioned, I've been off any and all medications for over 2 years and happily so. But in the meantime I was denied a 3rd class medical, no flying. I finally was able to get the "special issuance" medical. But at what cost? I've been required to send my complete medical history to the FAA. Years worth, at my own expense. Am still required to see a psychiatrist every month without fail, with extensive written records followed up by a annual written report from this same doctor. All at my expense. And it is alot. For what? To insure safety?! This senario is to continue indefinately. It has been a complete waste of my time and money and my doctors just to say, yes I'm still fine. Figure that one out.

posted by Mickey Lessley on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

If only this antidepressant decision had been made a few years earlier, perhaps Steve Fossett would still be alive today. Then again, being grounded for a year definitely isn't something that a lot of pilots can handle.

posted by Susan Simmons on April 7, 2010[report abuse]

The one year experience required will still keep most pilots from going to the doctor and getting the antidepressants. If you have to give up flying for one year most will respond just like the did before this rule.

Plus there are fair amounts of evidence(by other than the drug companies)that show placebos have a greater positive effect than anti-depressants.

posted by Roy Zesch on April 7, 2010[report abuse]

I am curious if anyone knows why paxil is not approved, or for that matter wellbutrin. I believe prozac xoloft paxil are all ssri's and somewhat interchangable to try to find a drug that works best. Wellbutrin is prescribed for smoking cessation in addition to depression.

I agree with Roy that pilots will avoid reporting anti depressant use, both for the reason that he states and for the stigma associated with anything involving psychiatry. Dr. Blue's description: "Mild to moderate depression is basically a medical illness with psychological symptoms." Seems to be an example of the squeamishness that aviation seems to have about this issue. (Couldn't you say that mild to moderate depression is basically a psychological state that is modified by taking a drug that changes brain chemistry?)

Susan's comment is the second time I have someone allude to Steve Fossett's accident as suicide. Why is this?

posted by robert miller on April 8, 2010[report abuse]

Hello to Brent--thanks for your service to EAA Aeromedical Council, and thanks for a good essay. I also fully support the FAA's decision on antidepressant use, because it is fact-based, rational, and humane. It is also politically risky for the agency leadership, and therefore, is courageous. I hope the new policy will be applied in an even-handed way and that it can be sustained in the face of uninformed disparagement by the fear-mongering media. For those of you who pile on against the agency, I can understand because of the personal losses. However, since I started flying in the early 1980s, the agency has made incredible progress in rationalizing aeromedical assessments and certifications-- diabetes, heart disease, and treated alcoholism being the most dramatic. There is room for improvement, but let's recognize the Air Surgeon's office for what they have accomplished. At some point, each of us will have to face the reality of not being fit to fly; the FAA gets to be the bad guy. In my experience with agency medical staff, they get no pleasure whatsoever in delivering the bad news. Hunter Heath III, M.D.

posted by Hunter Heath on April 8, 2010[report abuse]

Depressed pilot is not good for every one who are inside a plane. This is some motivative admission essay to keep a great mood.

posted by Larah Barnett on March 4, 2011[report abuse]

An essential article. Where else could anyone get grounded admission essays help that kind of information in such a complete way of writing.

posted by Larah Barnett on March 4, 2011[report abuse]

I have been searching for this visualization information for a long time and finally I have noticed this page. Sadly, but this post is written not in english so I can;t understand the basic information. Maybe can someone translate everything for me? I will be waiting for all your help.Engagement Rings

posted by maka saro on March 12, 2011[report abuse]

Well that's very informative article! I have suffered from mild depression for many years and stopped taking Zoloft in order to get a pilot medical. I am pleased at this new enlightenment but struggling with the thought that to go back on them would require a twelve month grounding. I'd rather stay off them. thanks for the sharing i like the way of your discussion. programming assignment | Coursework Help | essay writing service

posted by angel007 angel007 on March 17, 2011[report abuse]

Well that's superb work! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting.thanks custom essay writing | term paper help | dissertation writing help

posted by angel007 angel007 on March 17, 2011[report abuse]

être cialis ou viagra qui cialis achat alors vente cialis ce prix du cialis guérison achat cialis france mépris cialis 5 mg au acheter cialis en pharmacie son acheter du cialis sur internet les cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie feuilles cialis naturel l'anémie

posted by Stephen Anders on March 25, 2011[report abuse]

soutenir prix du cialis 20mg de viagra levitra cialis n'ai prix cialis pharmacie souvent cialis vente plein commande cialis n'étais prix cialis 10 mg sont cialis paiement paypal Je comprimes cialis le achat cialis sans ordonnance les generic4all cialis dans

posted by Stephen Anders on March 26, 2011[report abuse]

Wow, nice post,there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post.Thank you for sharing to us.Please one more post about that. Affiliate Script

posted by shurdul haji on April 2, 2011[report abuse]

Wow, nice post,there are many person searching about that now they will find enough resources by your post.Thank you for sharing to us.Please one more post about that. Affiliate Script

posted by shurdul haji on April 2, 2011[report abuse]

Wonderful source for my Aviation custom essays. Thank you for sharing and keep it up!

posted by Josh McAce on April 7, 2011[report abuse]

Thanks for sharing. Interesting essay help post.

posted by Kira Steels on April 7, 2011[report abuse]

Thanks for sharing. Interesting essay help post

posted by Kira Steels on April 7, 2011[report abuse]

Accidentally come here , I am incomparable to enjoy myself when i appreciate your beautiful article from my deep heart! essay writing write my essay buy research paper

posted by alice wonder on April 27, 2011[report abuse]

I easily get nice & updated information for research purposes... I'd definitely appreciate the work of the said blog owner... essay writing essay writers buy essay analysis essay

posted by alice wonder on April 27, 2011[report abuse]

Opened his sleepy eyes dim, I discovered the young time is passing so many groggy, like a never ending dream. Looking back at the past, once the ideal I do not know which is the intersection of life lost, and quiet. Eagerly looking forward to the future of the youth, although we have the Asics Gel Kayano 17, how much is left, what can we captivated. When the wind blows, my eyes always moist and run to see a piece of the leaves fluttering loose powder, went to the fate of death. Have always thought that, in any case life must be done: Life Like Summer Flowers brilliant and death like autumn leaves.Young days, to have different type of the Asics Whizzer Lo to enjoy blooming own light, to treasure that can not be discarded, to seize the little happiness in life, to give yourself a fresh smile every day when the sun comes to the world a beautiful smile. So after years of holding precipitation in the years to come thick memory ?to remember the Asics Onitsuka Tiger shoes,to nourish life, nursed back to health of fun.

posted by prada nancy on April 12, 2013[report abuse]

Opened his sleepy eyes dim, I discovered the young time is passing so many groggy, like a never ending dream. Looking back at the past, once the ideal I do not know which is the intersection of life lost, and quiet. Eagerly looking forward to the future of the youth, although we have the Asics Gel Kayano 17, how much is left, what can we captivated. When the wind blows, my eyes always moist and run to see a piece of the leaves fluttering loose powder, went to the fate of death. Have always thought that, in any case life must be done: Life Like Summer Flowers brilliant and death like autumn leaves.Young days, to have different type of the Asics Whizzer Lo to enjoy blooming own light, to treasure that can not be discarded, to seize the little happiness in life, to give yourself a fresh smile every day when the sun comes to the world a beautiful smile. So after years of holding precipitation in the years to come thick memory ?to remember the Asics Onitsuka Tiger shoes,to nourish life, nursed back to health of fun.

posted by prada nancy on April 12, 2013[report abuse]

Opened his sleepy eyes dim, I discovered the young time is passing so many groggy, like a never ending dream. Looking back at the past, once the ideal I do not know which is the intersection of life lost, and quiet. Eagerly looking forward to the future of the youth, although we have the Asics Gel Kayano 17, how much is left, what can we captivated. When the wind blows, my eyes always moist and run to see a piece of the leaves fluttering loose powder, went to the fate of death. Have always thought that, in any case life must be done: Life Like Summer Flowers brilliant and death like autumn leaves.Young days, to have different type of the Asics Whizzer Lo to enjoy blooming own light, to treasure that can not be discarded, to seize the little happiness in life, to give yourself a fresh smile every day when the sun comes to the world a beautiful smile. So after years of holding precipitation in the years to come thick memory ?to remember the Asics Onitsuka Tiger shoes,to nourish life, nursed back to health of fun.

posted by prada nancy on April 12, 2013[report abuse]


Post a Comment
Already Registered?

E-mail Address:


Password:


Forgot your password?



Commenting Rules

AVweb welcomes responses to our blog postings. However, we ask that you follow some simple rules. We're not interested in flame wars, thanks. If you are, there are plenty of newsgroups to pick from.

Please keep it civil. Save the name-calling and insults for private e-mail or newsgroups.

No anonymous responses, please. If you feel compelled to comment on a blog, use your real name as registered with AVweb. (If your name isn't already associated with your account, see the blog section of our "Help" page for instructions on how to add it.) You can always keep your name out of the public conversation by sending us an e-mail instead of commenting.

Please keep it on topic. Focus on the topic at hand; this isn't an open forum for everything under the sun. (We have a letters column for that, and you're welcome to contact us there with any topic you like.)

 
New to AVweb? Register for Free!

* First Name:


* Last Name:


* E-mail Address:


* Password:
 (4-16 characters)

* Confirm Password:


 Subscribe to AVwebFlash

Yes!
Please e-mail me AVwebFlash every Monday and Thursday morning.

Subscribe to Avweb Biz

Yes!
Please e-mail me AVweb Biz twice a month (every other Wednesday morning).

Check this box to receive e-mail notifications when new comments are posted to this page. (E-mails contain a link to discontinue notifications.)
* Comments:



JavaScript Menus and DHTML Menus Powered by Milonic

Copyright Aviation Publishing Group. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Contact Us | XMLRSS | Site Map | Top