HOME
REGISTER/LOGIN
FREE NEWSLETTER
XML|RSS
Advanced Search
PODCAST
VIDEO
AVWEB INSIDER
AVweb Insider

April 1, 2010

When Following the TFR to the Letter Isn't Enough

By Jeff Van West

As I write this, it's the first of April -- April Fool's Day -- and I spent the morning boring holes in the sky around Portland, Maine to shoot some video for upcoming YouTube spots. We were sure to get a real briefing for this flight because our President is due in this afternoon. There were no changes to the 14:30 TFR and no special NOTAMs for Portland. We launched with confidence.

No, we didn't run into any Blackhawks. But I was chatting with a lineman after landing and was told the ramp at Portland was closing at 13:55. Excuse me? What if someone lands at 14:00, a full half-hour before TFR goes into effect?

"Uh, I think the Tower is going to turn them away."

That didn't sound right to me, so I did some asking around, including a call to the TRACON (Portland Approach), which sits right below the Tower cab. The ramp was scheduled to close before 14:00 with no movements allowed except for scheduled air carriers. Would the Tower turn away arrivals?

"No, as far as air traffic is concerned, the TFR starts at 14:30."

"But you can't issue them a clearance to taxi to the ramp?"

"Uh, I don't know. That's a ramp issue. Maybe we'd park them across the road."

The "across the road" reference is our FedEx and maintenance ramp on the west side of Runway 18. There's no access to get back around to the GA area of the airport except a long walk.

Picture this scenario: You're based at Portland and were away on a trip when this TFR was announced a few days ago. You change your plans to get back as soon as you can, but it's going to be close so you check the start time of that TFR on the way. You find out it's still 14:30. So you skip a fuel stop and land with acceptable reserves at 13:57, feeling great that you beat the deadline. You call Ground for taxi and are told that… you can't. You can't park. You can't get fuel. You can't even taxi the to the only FBO and get out of your plane. And, by the time you figure this out and sit dumbfounded for a moment, you can't leave because the TFR will activate before you can clear the airspace (not to mention the tight fuel).

Per the TFR and all NOTAMs the airport is open, but -- April Fool -- it's actually the runways that are open. The rest of the airport is closed.

Is it really too much to ask that these logistics are run past someone who might bother to think them through? We're now all trained to search for the NOTAM that says, "Jump" so we can shout, "How high?" But do us the favor of actually issuing a NOTAM with little details like whether or not the airplane can park.

The lineman said there was a Lear scheduled to come in at 14:00 that hadn't canceled yet. I cheeked Flight Aware when I got to my office an hour later and didn't see a Lear in the list.

Maybe he got lucky and someone let him in on the joke.


Comments

Typical result of disinterested desk-monkeys making policy. Not only does the left hand not know what the right hand is doing, it assumes the right hand has been amputated and thus it's actions don't matter.

posted by Peter Buckley on April 1, 2010[report abuse]

Yes, asking the government to think somthing through is too much to ask, but we all knew that already.

posted by Barrett Roessler on April 1, 2010[report abuse]

Okay, we'll just shut down on the runway until the ramp opens.

posted by Kenton Koran on April 3, 2010[report abuse]

Not newsworthy. Lots of airports go beyond what is listed on a TFR or a NOTAM. I've been escorted away from my aircraft for "security reasons" because the airport manager did not want people on the ramp because of the "risk". That hard part is that you can't raise your voice and call them crazy.

posted by Mark Fraser on April 5, 2010[report abuse]

Let us not forget that even highly respected aviation journalists like Paul Bertorelli honestly believe that being imprisoned in your own aircraft in just this kind of scenario (the one suggested by Jeff Van West) does not represent a palpable loss of freedom since 9/11/01.

posted by Bruce Liddel on April 6, 2010[report abuse]

Not interesting. Lots of airports go beyond what is listed on a TFR or a NOTAM. I've been escorted away from my aircraft for "security reasons" because the airport manager did not want people on the ramp because of the "risk". That hard part is that you can't raise your voice and call them crazy. dissertation help | assignment help | essay help

posted by james kerry on February 25, 2011[report abuse]

The beauty of these blogging engines and CMS platforms is the lack of limitations and ease of manipulation that allows developers to implement rich content and 'skin' the site in such a way that with very little effort one would never notice what it is making the site tick all without limiting content and effectiveness.Mohegan Sun Arena

posted by maka saro on March 9, 2011[report abuse]

Couldnt be written any better. Reading this post reminds me of my old room mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this article to him. Pretty sure he will have a good read. Thanks for sharing!Language translation

posted by maka saro on March 11, 2011[report abuse]

No fools in the sky, eh? Still adore your work. buy research paper

posted by Fawken Melvin on March 17, 2011[report abuse]

Hello Jeff, Talk about a frustrating day. I feel your pain. From Richard, Nopalea wellness from the desert.

posted by Richard Reese on March 23, 2011[report abuse]

hey, reading your post reminds me of an article. it was about this type of frustration. BAD LUCK.... portable dvd player

posted by Galib H. on March 29, 2011[report abuse]

I find myself looking at the images and deciphering what is happening at the moment – which is opposite of what picture books makes us do – we look at text first, and then over on the picture to reaffirm what we see in our minds.

assignment writing assignment help assignment writing

posted by jason fisher on April 14, 2011[report abuse]

Not cool. Nobody wants to be imprisoned in an aircraft. Millionaire Mind Intensive Melbourne

posted by AJ Perez on April 17, 2011[report abuse]

April fools is a great time to write this kind of article...not sure if I would usually read this knid of thing but glad I did.

I definitely think that the logistics should have been run past someone first.

Milton R Shimano Stella 20000

posted by milton rich on April 20, 2011[report abuse]

Hey Jeff, your day is so much frustrating, I never liked 1st of April. I really can feel your pain: Storage Auctions

posted by Daniel David on April 28, 2011[report abuse]

Not cool. Nobody wants to be imprisoned in an aircraft. Millionaire Mind Intensive Melbourne

MQL Programming

posted by passion lab on July 24, 2011[report abuse]

April fools is a great time to write this kind of article...not sure if I would usually read this knid of thing but glad I did. Russian Translations

posted by passion lab on August 14, 2011[report abuse]

term paper writing

posted by adam jones on October 31, 2011[report abuse]


Post a Comment
Already Registered?

E-mail Address:


Password:


Forgot your password?



Commenting Rules

AVweb welcomes responses to our blog postings. However, we ask that you follow some simple rules. We're not interested in flame wars, thanks. If you are, there are plenty of newsgroups to pick from.

Please keep it civil. Save the name-calling and insults for private e-mail or newsgroups.

No anonymous responses, please. If you feel compelled to comment on a blog, use your real name as registered with AVweb. (If your name isn't already associated with your account, see the blog section of our "Help" page for instructions on how to add it.) You can always keep your name out of the public conversation by sending us an e-mail instead of commenting.

Please keep it on topic. Focus on the topic at hand; this isn't an open forum for everything under the sun. (We have a letters column for that, and you're welcome to contact us there with any topic you like.)

 
New to AVweb? Register for Free!

* First Name:


* Last Name:


* E-mail Address:


* Password:
 (4-16 characters)

* Confirm Password:


 Subscribe to AVwebFlash

Yes!
Please e-mail me AVwebFlash every Monday and Thursday morning.

Subscribe to Avweb Biz

Yes!
Please e-mail me AVweb Biz twice a month (every other Wednesday morning).

Check this box to receive e-mail notifications when new comments are posted to this page. (E-mails contain a link to discontinue notifications.)
* Comments:



JavaScript Menus and DHTML Menus Powered by Milonic

Copyright Aviation Publishing Group. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Advertise | Contact Us | XMLRSS | Site Map | Top